Harness or Collar: The Great Dog Debate

You’re about to take your dog for a walk and you reach for a leash, but what are you clipping it onto: a harness or a collar? This question has sparked debates among dog owners for years. What’s more important? Comfort? Control? Safety? It’s a decision that every dog parent has to make, and it’s not a one-size-fits-all answer.

If you’re a seasoned pet owner, you’ve probably tried both at different times. But if you’re a new dog parent, you might be a bit overwhelmed with the options. The question is simple, yet the answer is complex and layered. It depends on various factors including your dog’s breed, size, and temperament, as well as your lifestyle and walking habits. 

In this article, we’ll look at the pros and cons of both options. Remember, every dog is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. Therefore, it’s important to understand your dog’s size, breed, behavior, and health conditions before choosing between a harness and a collar.

The Classic Collar

Dog collars are the classic choice. They wrap around your dog’s neck and usually have a ring to attach a leash. Collars are practical, easy to put on, and perfect for attaching identification tags. They’re often more comfortable for dogs to wear around the clock, so you’ll be confident knowing your dog’s tags are always attached. They come in various materials, designs, and sizes allowing you to find one that fits as well as showcases your dog’s personality. 

For dogs that don’t pull or dart, a collar can be an excellent option. They provide ample control for calm, well-behaved canines, making your walks a breeze. They provide enough control for basic commands without putting too much pressure on your furry friend’s neck.

However, it’s crucial to remember that collars can pose risks.  For dogs prone to pulling, a collar can put undue pressure on their neck. Excessive pulling can lead to neck injuries and breathing problems. Dogs with respiratory issues or neck injuries should avoid collars, as they can exacerbate these problems. Also, dogs that are escape artists might find it easier to slip out of a collar, especially if it is fit too loose.

The Handy Harness

A dog harness wraps around your dog’s chest and back, distributing the force when your dog pulls. This takes the pressure away from your dog’s neck, reducing the risk of injury. Harnesses come in different styles, including back-clip, front-clip, and dual-clip, each serving a specific purpose. They’re particularly useful for puppies, small dogs, or dogs with health issues like tracheal collapse. 

Harnesses offer a higher level of control, which comes in handy with dogs that are pullers or are still in training. A harness can be a game-changer for dogs with mobility issues, as harnesses often come with handles that allow you to assist your pet. They’re also harder to escape from, which is a bonus for those crafty canines who love a good game of chase.

However, harnesses aren’t without their drawbacks. Some dogs find them uncomfortable or restricting, especially during the adjustment period. A gradual introduction and positive reinforcement can go a long way in making your dog feel comfortable in a harness. Another challenge with harnesses is they can be a bit more complicated to put on, especially for wiggly pups. Harnesses come in a variety of styles and sizes and it may take a few tries to find the perfect fit for your pooch. And though they come in many colors, they don’t have quite the same variety of design options as collars do.

Finding the Perfect Fit

When it comes to choosing between a collar and a harness, it ultimately depends on your dog’s needs and behaviors. If your dog is calm, well-behaved, and doesn’t have any respiratory or neck issues, a collar might be a good fit. If your dog is a puller, is still in training, or has a health condition that could be worsened by a collar, a harness could be the way to go.

Keep in mind that this isn’t a one-size-fits-all situation. The goal is to ensure your dog’s safety and comfort. It’s crucial to monitor your dog’s comfort and behavior with the chosen equipment. Don’t be afraid to experiment until you find the perfect fit.

So, whether you’re team collar or team harness, remember the goal is to ensure enjoyable, safe walks for both you and your furry friend. After all, those daily adventures are about more than just exercise; they’re about bonding and making memories with your four-legged family member.

  1. We use both. Our dogs have collars on 100% of the time because their ID, rabies and city pet license tags are attached. When it is time for a walk we harness up. The leash is attached to the harness and off we go.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The internet’s most dog-friendly website. Sidewalk Dog is your go-to resource for all things dog. Trusted by more than 250,000 dog people around the world.

Join the Pack